"The Witch" is the film debut of writer and directer Robert Eggars. The film stars Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin, the daughter of English immigrants to colonial America in the sixteen hundreds. This is the story of how she and her entire family decent into madness after their newest baby disappears.
That is all you need to know. I don't want to spoil anything further because trust me when I say that this movie gets most of its strengths from its surprises, twists and turns.
The performances in this film were all outstanding. The reason for that being, they have to make Shakespearean dialogue sound natural in an every-day context. Words like "thus", "thou", "thy", "ist" and "hither". To make dialogue like that sound natural is not an easy thing to pull off.
The writing was also fantastic. The film is written in such a way that feels dream-like and unreal. This amplifies and secretes a tone that is uncommon in most horror films.
And yes this movie is scary. Very scary. Scarier than most horror films made in the past ten years. Why? Because it uses the Stanley Kubrick methodology of horror. The film starts out being pretty straightforward. But as the conflict escalates, the story becomes enriched with ambiguity that makes the story stranger and stranger. Finally in the third act, something happens that throws everything that happens into question. This method worked in "The Shining", "The Babadook" and it works here just as well.
What makes this movie as suspenseful as it is is that everyone is a suspect. Nobody is out of the question because they are all religious and they are all sinners. One of the children, Calab is even infatuated with his sister, Thomasin. Its that extreme!
That being said the character's sins are not subtle. The movie goes out of its way to prove to the audience that these characters are not perfect. That's kind of a shame since every other aspect to the storytelling is super secretive and analytical.
The characters were also not as fleshed out as the could have been. Also a problem because this movie is 90 percent build-up.
The Witch is an exceptionally strong debut from Robert Eggars. Although the characters are not as well developed as they could have been, the film's finale and riviting tension more then make up for it.
4.3 out of 5 stars